California voters rejected Proposition 40, a proposed one-time 5% tax on the state’s billionaires, according to an Associated Press determination reported on November 10, 2026. The result left economists divided over whether campaign spending, the measure’s design or broader resistance to wealth taxes best explains its defeat.
UC Berkeley economist Gabriel Zucman, a supporter of wealth taxes, argued that opponents’ spending was critical. Opponents spent almost $400 million fighting Proposition 40, including on competing ballot measures. Zucman said they spent more than $300 million on ads, while the other side spent comparatively little. In his view, that imbalance could have been decisive in a close vote.
Stanford economist Joshua Rauh, a critic of Proposition 40, questioned whether advertising was the main explanation. He compared county-level support for the measure with support for Kamala Harris in the 2024 presidential election. Some strongly Democratic Bay Area counties showed a particularly large gap, he said. Rauh suggested that voters near billionaires and the businesses they fund may have been more skeptical of the tax. That is his interpretation of the voting pattern, not a settled explanation of it.
The proposal also drew objections to its specifics. It would have allocated 90% of projected revenue to health care and the remaining 10% to food assistance and education-related programs. The California Teachers Association opposed it, arguing that it shortchanged public schools and would not provide lasting funding. Governor Gavin Newsom opposed the state measure as well, favoring a national minimum tax on billionaires; he argued that wealthy residents could move to lower-tax states.
The defeat does not settle the prospects for a federal wealth tax. Zucman expected the issue to receive attention in the next Congress, while Rauh expected further proposals but saw little chance of a law passing with President Trump in the White House. Rauh also argued that a federal wealth tax could face constitutional restrictions on “direct taxes.” Legal scholars disagree about whether those restrictions would apply.


